Last week I read from The Master’s Seminary
Journal an article titled Preservation of the
Bible: Providential or Miraculous? The Biblical View by Jon
Rehurek. Afterward I read Daniel Wallace’s Inspiration,
Preservation, and New Testament Textual Criticism. The general
conclusion of these authors is that “The preservation of God’s revelation is
the lesson in many of the passages, but no explicit indication applies them
directly to written Scripture or to how and when a promise of general
preservation would be fulfilled” and that “the case for providential
preservation must rest upon theological grounds through the historical (i.e.,
canonicity) and manuscript evidence (i.e., textual criticism) rather than upon
exegetical grounds.”[i] Simply put, the Bible does
not teach the preservation of the Scriptures, the only reason we know they are preserved is because we have them, and
they have not been preserved in a way any more special than
the writings of, say, Confucius or Machiavelli. Another leading author who takes this
position is W. Edward Glenny in “The Preservation of Scripture” in the book The Bible Version Debate: The Perspective of
Central Baptist Theological Seminary. This is included as Chapter 4 in One Bible
Only?: Examining Exclusive Claims for the King James Bible.[ii]
Rehurek’s main point (as well as Wallace and Glenny)
is that there is no doctrine of preservation of the written Scriptures taught in
the Bible, or in other words, the Bible does not promise that the words of the
Bible will be preserved in written form. In contrast to these authors W. W.
Combs, in the The
Preservation of Scripture, presents his view that the Bible itself teaches
a doctrine of preservation of Scripture.
Over the next few days I would like to investigate this topic (d.v.).
Links to other posts in this series
- Preservation: Not a KJVO debate
- Preservation: Historical considerations, continuity
- Preservation: Historical considerations, Confessions
- Preservation: Historical considerations, Christian individuals
- Preservation: Public access or availability
- Preservation: The texts No. 1
- Preservation: The texts No. 2
- Preservation: The texts No. 3
- Preservation: Concluding thoughts
- Criticizing Professor Wallace
- Give me my Model T
[i] Quoted from Rehurek’s Preservation of the Bible: Providential or
Miraculous?
[ii] “Google Preview” only
No comments:
Post a Comment