Translate

Sunday, January 09, 2022

Follow the science?

Maybe the problem is that those who use the phrase do not even know what it means.

“But of course, you know, children aren’t supposed to die,” said CDC Director Dr. Rochelle Walensky in an interview with Bret Baier in which he challenged her to call out a Supreme Court Justice for spreading COVID Misinformation.

I can’t say how many times I have heard someone say “children aren’t supposed to die” – even people whose scientific or religious knowledge teaches them that is not a true statement.[i] And yet, many of us just shake our heads in solemn agreement, as if it is a universal truth. Well, I ain’t gonna take it anymore. Today I resist.

There is nothing in our scientific or religious knowledge that tells us that children aren’t suppose to die. In fact, everything in our ubiquitous learned experience denies that statement. And yet we make it, and make it, and make it.

What we mean is that we don’t want to see children suffer and die. We wish to see them live long and prosper. And hopefully that feeling is universally true for us, one and all. “Children aren’t supposed to die” expresses a yen within us. Nevertheless, the statement is not true – it is emotional, a statement or expression of feeling. For persons in places of leadership in religion, science, health care, and so on to assert such as simple truth is misleading and unhelpful.

“Let me not see the death of the child.”

“the child died”

“it is appointed unto men once to die”


[i] Another way I have heard it is “children aren’t supposed to die before their parents.”

No comments: