Translate

Tuesday, December 05, 2023

Early Baptist Churches in the Northeastern U.S.

Recently our daughter treated the “old folks” to a vacation with her to the northeastern United States. We saw many marvelous things while there – from fall foliage to Mount Washington to Niagara Falls to the Cincinnati Zoo. Part of the trip included visiting the sites of some historic Baptist churches. Here is a brief report of what we saw. Some locations were deliberate encounters, and some we happened across while traveling. I will take them in chronological order.

First Baptist Church, Providence, Rhode Island.

It was dark when we arrived at this location, but I was able to get some pictures. This church at Providence claims to be the oldest Baptist Church in America. The church claims its organization from 1638. Roger Williams gathered a congregation in 1638, but it is not clear that he was a Baptist at the time. I consider Williams a “halfway Baptist” – one who accepted some of the principles of the Baptists, and may have connected himself with them for a very brief period but was never fully committed to Baptist doctrine. Additionally, it appears that the Williams church died out, and the current First Baptist Church is the continuation of a General Baptist Church organized in 1652. Nevertheless, they claim to be the first Baptist Church in America. The building used by First Baptist Providence was built in 1775. The church is now a very liberal society affiliated with the ABCUSA and American Baptist Churches of Rhode Island.

United Baptist Church, Newport, Rhode Island.

The Baptist Church at Newport was organized in 1638 by John Clarke. It is the oldest Baptist Church in the United States and America. The building in which the church currently meets was built in 1826. The church is affiliated with the ABCUSA and American Baptist Churches of Rhode Island, but appears to be a much more conservative evangelical church than the one at Providence. They hold the New Hampshire Confession of Faith as their doctrinal statement.

“Sometime during the year 1638, it is believed, the church now known as The United Baptist Church, John Clarke Memorial, of Newport, was organized and he [i.e., John Clarke] became its first pastor, holding that office until his death. He is believed to have been the first American Baptist pastor, and it is thought by many that the church he founded and served as pastor is entitled to the distinction of being the oldest Baptist church in this country.” Wilbur Nelson, The Life of Dr. John Clarke, Newport, RI: Men’s Bible Class of First Baptist Church, 1924, p. 17. 


Pennepack Baptist Church, Busleton, Pennsylvania.

The Pennepack Church was organized in 1688 by Elias Keach, son of English Baptist leader Benjamin Keach. Though not the first Baptist church constituted in Pennsylvania, it is the oldest Baptist church in Pennsylvania in continuous existence. The first meeting house was built in 1707, and the current building was built on the same location in 1805. The church is affiliated with the ABCUSA.


Welsh Tract Baptist Church, Newark, Delaware.

The Welsh Tract Baptist Church was organized in Wales in 1701, and then moved to the “Welsh Tract” purchased from William Penn in 1703. The current meeting house was built in 1746. The picture from one side (below) shows a brick wall repair of a cannon ball hole made during the Revolutionary War Battle of Cooch’s Bridge. The meeting house is surrounded by the cemetery on three sides, which includes burials of early members and pastors. The Welsh Tract Church rejected the concept of parachurch societies for carrying out the Lord’s work, and followed the “old school” local church ministry. Welsh Tract Old School Baptist Church meets here monthly on second Sundays.


Baptist Church, Hopewell, New Jersey.

The church at Hopewell was constituted in 1715. Some of its first members were baptized by the Pennepack Church in Pennsylvania. The Old School Baptist Meeting House at Hopewell was built in 1747. No congregation currently meets here. Declaration of Independence signer John Hart is buried in the graveyard, as well as Joab Houghton, who in front of this meeting house made a call for volunteers for the Continental Army.


Second Baptist Church, Harbourton, Hopewell, New Jersey.

This building built in 1879 was once the home of the 2nd Hopewell Baptist Church. There was a church meeting here by 1803, when the cemetery was established. The Baptist Church disbanded around 1930. The Harbourton Cemetery Association was incorporated in 1931 to maintain the cemetery – which had been owned by the church. I believe a generic community church probably meets here now.

Old Stone Church, Old School Baptist, Locktown, New Jersey.

It is not clear just when this church at Locktown was constituted, but at least by 1819 when Old Stone Church building was built. The nearby Kingstown Baptist Church held meetings in Kingstown as well as in this area. Eventually a church was established here as well. The church disbanded in the 1960s, and the location is now maintained as an historic building by the “Friends of the Locktown Stone Church, Inc.”


Union Baptist Church, Mystic, Connecticut.

This church building in Mystic, Connecticut was originally built in 1829 for use by different denominations. Some members from the First Baptist Church founded the Third Baptist Church in 1831. The Third Baptist congregation met here. As different groups built their own buildings and moved out of this location, this meeting house was left to the use of the Baptists. In 1861, the Third Baptist Church merged with the Second Baptist Church to form Union Baptist Church. The current building itself is also a combination of the Second and Third Baptist meeting houses, the building of Second Baptist being moved to the back of the original building. The Second Baptist Church dated back to 1765, when it was organized in Fort Hill, Groton, Connecticut.


Wearts Corner Baptist Church, Wertsville, New Jersey.

The Baptist Church in Wertsville, New Jersey was formed by “New School” Baptists who left the “Old School” congregations at Hopewell and Flemington. These departing Baptists supported missionary societies and other extra-church organizations. They had organized by 1834, when the stone meeting house was constructed. The congregation ceased to meet in 1908. The building is now a residence. (Apparently also called Amwell Baptist Church, which name is on the gable front.)

Baptist Church, Weston, Vermont.

The “church on the hill” building was built in 1838. It was originally built by the Baptists, so there was a Baptist Church in Weston by that time. However, the building is now home to the Weston Community Church. It is said to be one of the most photographed buildings in southern Vermont.

Tremont Temple Baptist Church, Boston, Massachusetts.

Tremont Temple Baptist Church was founded in Boston in 1839. My understanding is that it was a Free Baptist Church—believed in a general atonement and free (that is, open) communion. The building was completed in 1894. Several stories, it is now used by others as well as the church. The old sign over the church door says “The First Integrated Church in America.” I am unsure what nuance they use to make that claim. Many Baptist churches in America had integrated congregations long before this. The church affiliates with the ABCUSA, but also is part of the 9Marks orbit.

Pawcatuck Seventh Day Baptist Church, Westerly, Rhode Island.

There were Baptists in England and America who worshipped on the 7th day rather than the 1st day. This church house is the meeting location for the Pawcatuck Seventh Day Baptist Church in Westerly, which was organized in 1840. Apparently, based on there being two signs, and considering the Seventh Day Baptists meet on Saturday, another church called “The Church at Westerly” meets in the building on Sunday.

The church locations we visited cover a founding history of over 400 years, 1638-1840. Obviously, there were other locations we could have seen, but these constitute two that I was determined to see – Newport and Welsh Tract – and others that my daughter determined we would be close to, or places we happened to drive by. In most cases the buildings were locked, no one was around, and we were unable to go inside (Welsh Tract & Tremont Temple being exceptions). I did not do detailed research on the foundings of these churches, but generally accepted the dates they proposed. We saw other non-Baptist historical buildings, such as the Old North Church where the lanterns of warning were hung prior to “the midnight ride of Paul Revere” and William Dawes. I thought I would share a bit of history and a few pictures.

No comments: